| YEAR | WINNER | JUDGE |
|---|---|---|
| 1976 | Angela Carpadus | Lisa Vinyard |
| 1977 | (No Classes Offered) | |
| 1978 | Marcy Bankus | Jack Magoffin |
| 1979 | Francesca Weisser | Peter J Emily |
| 1980 | Francesca Weisser | Carrie Stuart-Parks |
| 1981 | (No Classes Offered) | |
| 1982 | Don VandenAvond | Jack Magoffin |
| 1983 | Renee Marcy | Carrie Stuart-Parks |
| 1984 | Janelle VandenAvond | Charles Durand |
| 1985 | (No Classes Offered) | |
| 1986 | Brian Mueller | Carolyn Hardy |
| 1987 | Brian Mueller | Susan T. Hon |
| 1988 | Christopher Cort | Robert Forsyth |
| 1989 | Robert Coombs | Carrie Stuart-Parks |
| 1990 | Ellen VandenAvond | Rita McKissack |
| 1991 | Jeremy Butler | John Hannum |
| 1992 | Paula Butler | JoAnn Teems |
| 1993 | Paula Butler | John P. Linnehan |
| 1994 | Heidi Hoffman | John Hannum |
| 1995 | Sara Rausch | Whitney Coombs |
| 1996 | Jaclyn Kenniger | Robert Brown |
| 1997 | Kate Stewart | Carolyn Hardy |
| 1998 | Jaclyn Kenniger | Mary Lou VandenAvond |
| 1999 | Claudette Du Pont | Vince Chianese |
| 2000 | Michael McGuire | Joan G. Reid |
| 2001 | CJ Dyment | Bobert Brown |
| 2002 | Brendan Sherman | Valerie Brown |
| 2003 | Casey Pawl | Edd Biven |
| 2004 | Brendan Sherman | Whitney Coombs |
| 2005 | Casey Pawl | Susan Malinowski |
| 2006 | Stephanie VanLanon | Ruth Marcy |
| 2007 | Jonathan Johnson | Nancy Coombs |
| 2008 | Stephanie VanLanen | Carrie Stuart-Parks |
| 2009 | Abbygail Chrysler | Jean Pero |
| 2010 | Jamie Lamphier | Robert Brown |
| 2011 | Lauren Hull | Jean Fournier |
| 2012 | Lauren Hull | Ellen VandenAvond |
| 2013 | Lauren Hull | Carrie Stuart-Parks |
| 2014 | Mitcheal Butler | Vince Chianese |
| 2015 | Lauren Hull | Peter Emily |
| 2016 | Lauren Hull | Whitney Coombs |
| 2017 | Rheanna Fitzgerald | Casey Pawl |
| 2018 | Cassidy Hanover | Nancy Coombs |
| 2019 | Cassidy Hanover | Robert Brown |
| 2020 | Olivia Maciuba | Jean Pero |
| 2021 | Olivia Maciuba | Tami Green |
| 2022 | Cates Tamburrino | Carrie Stuart Parks |
| 2023 | No Entry | |
| 2024 | Olivia Maciuba | Claudette Du Pont |
| 2025 | Olivia Maciuba | Dr. Patricia Princehouse |
| 2026 | Abigail Metish | Stephen Cabral |
